The Excellent Personality of the Destroyer: Zoey's Malformed Role in Being a DIK
It is a true narrative shame, then, that her structural role turns her into the ultimate Destroyer of Paths, and as a protagonist in her own aside, causing a giant narrative shift that didn't need to exist.
1. The "Too-Perfect" Fantasy: An Authorial Insert with Zero Campus Stakes
On paper, Zoey's personality is virtually flaw-free. However, this level of polish creates its own writing issues.
Yes, the dreaded Mary Sue or Authorial Insert trap many writers have succumb too; DPC is no better, despite self-stating "no lazy writing". (Sure.) Zoey is tailored almost too perfectly to the MC.
- She loves video games and music
- Grew up with him for years in high school
- Is a rebel like him
- Thinks about him all the time
- Has striking tattoos (Melanie? Pssh, Zoey's tattoos have an entire "Episode" dedicated to them)
- Displays high visual style and physical attractiveness
- Fits right in with "the guys" and has an outgoing, positive, friendly personality
- Gets along with almost the entire female cast immediately; save for Becky (but that's a joke at this point.
- Even her family back home loves the MC, whom he visits for Christmas.
But aside from the MC...she has no reason to be on B&R's campus. Unlike every other core love interest, Zoey has no stake in the B&R ecosystem. She just pops in to various parties...because she's back at home and can make the trek to visit him. She faces no fraternity politics, no HOTs rivalry, no academic pressure, no local family baggage, no relationship issues, and no financial issues. She is an artist who wants to pursue design, but her sole functional purpose in the main plot is her romantic availability to the MC.
She was literally dropped in to set off a romance bomb. Which technically could have worked fine, as the old flame rekindled coming back trope. Instead, it's a destructive occurrence that turns all of our MC's romantic locked in girlfriend choices into a "whoops. Sorry!" That doesn't make for good AVN pathing, nor good character development for a protagonist.
2. The Pacing Nightmare: The Interlude and Illusion of Choice
Having a lost childhood flame return is a standard romance trope, and Zoey's presence is teased from Episodes 1-3 through backstory flashbacks (most notably while the MC confides in Isabella at lunch). However, physically throwing her into the Episode mix, by introducing her via a dedicated Interlude Episode between Episodes 8 and 9 creates massive structural problems.
- [Episodes 1-8: B&R] Campus & Core Routes Established
- [The Interlude: Zoey's Escapade Side-Story] = Halts Narrative Pacing
- [Episodes 9-11: Zoey Arrives at B&R] = "Destroyer of Paths" Pivot
Forcing players -- who waited nearly a year in real-time for episode updates -- to sit through a standalone chapter set in another state (or proverbially far away enough) completely disrupts narrative momentum. Who is this? Why should we care? Players with a positive outlook said this was a nice change of pace and felt different with the new drawing mini games; which is to argue the main story is uninteresting and needed an infusion of a female protagonist Mary Sue like character for one episode, is nothing more than a cope for a bad narrative. And even more boring mini games.
Giving Zoey a temporary DIK/CHICK scoring mechanic during the Interlude was an illusion of choice. It changes minor dialogue flavors, but she remains fundamentally the exact same MC-obsessed character regardless of player input. This is seen after subsequent playthroughs by allowing the player to completely skip the Interlude option, and simply choosing a single choice that determines this new "personality". Interlude feels tacked on, dramatically irrelevant, has forgetful characters, and is ultimately a waste of time.
Then there are the irrelevant side dramas of characters we don't care about. While long-distance phone calls with her local support group do add psychological detail, they hold zero stakes for the active characters and events at B&R.
If you remove the Interlude entirely and simply have Zoey arrive at Neil's doorstep in Episode 9 based on her established flashback history:
- The plot loses nothing.
- We were already introduced to Zoey through flashbacks and given essential info.
- The main story gains it's normal momentum.
- We get a more effective cliffhanger from a character we know enough about.
- No tonal, setting, or dramatic shift
- Potentially, ideally: more MC content. As in an actual episode
3. The "Destroyer of Paths" and the Invalidation of Player Agency
Zoey's romantic climax occurs at the end of Episode 11, where she states her feelings and presents the player with an explicit "choose me" option. (Worse still, it sounds insulting if she went DIK. How romantic, Zoey. It's as if the author knowns his major writing technique is forcing the narrative. Let's force the dialogue as well.) In a potential 14-15 episode AVN, introducing a brand-new main route after ~75% of the story is complete invalidates years of player investment. Only completionists play an AVN just to start again to facilitate a broken choice in a late game event.
By Episode 8 Crossroads, the player has already made high-stakes decisions to lock into a singular, dedicated main path. Selecting Zoey in Episode 11 forces the MC to abandon every single established romance, throwing away years of hard choices and expectations. Breaking hearts, making the MC feel apologetic and sad, because "golly, Zoey said she loved me!" Once again, forcing players to do a Monk run for the sake of a new character inclusion (e.g. Nikita), also so we don't start breaking hearts. Why DPC wants us to go through his broken game multiple times has got to be some kind of sadistic design choice.
Chosen Core routes Destroyed:
- Maya & Josy (Throuple & now Individual, thanks
DPCJosy) - Isabella
- Jill
- Sage
- Quinn
- Nicole
- Lily
Zoey's not done yet. She also destroys Potential Side/Casual Paths, and locking them out on Others.
- Sally
- Bianca (ugh, who does this)
- Sarah
- Melanie
- Nikita (yet another Monk run)
- ...I'm sure DPC will create yet another option in Episode 13 that gets locked out.
Zoey's late-game option acts as a wrecking ball to the choice-driven structure the game spent eleven Episodes establishing, with multiple playthroughs for dedicated paths, forcing players to abandon multi-season/year commitments for a late arrival.
CTRL is truly the hardest hit key on playing Being a DIK. And if you're not playing with mods and have mini games turned on, how much time do you really have?
4. Character Strengths vs. Conceptual Flaws
| Character Trait | Narrative & Mechanical Execution |
|---|---|
| Emotional Maturity | High. She processes her feelings honestly, avoids manipulation, and never guilt-trips the MC. She's introspective and deals with her feelings and choices with her family, and a remote support group when needed. |
| Relational Dynamics | Excellent. She integrates smoothly with Neil, the DIKs, and the broader cast. |
| Conflict & Drama | Minimal. Her conflicts (like her Thanksgiving panic attack, complete with a running animation) feel artificially injected to give her, yet again, temporary narrative focus. |
| Roleplay Integration | Weak. Her late "choose me" option forces a high-CHICK/monogamous choice even onto players running casual, Other's, or DIK paths. |
5. How Zoey Should Have Been Handled
Zoey could have been one of the strongest inclusions in the game if her implementation followed cleaner AVN design principles.
- Introduce Zoey as early as possible. Make her a surprise active transfer or local presence in Season 1 (Episodes 1-3) alongside the main cast. Similar to how you have options to run toward when trying to spend the night (Derek, Sage, Isabella, after the M&J reveal), Zoey could've been a default option. She can still be a lone wolf throughout the story if needed, or be integrated into a frat without all the problems that involves. Minimal character change. Zoey always has your back.
- Have Zoey earn her "I love you." All the other characters have organic love declarations and player Episode 8 Crossroads path choices. Allow her romantic path to compete organically at the Episode 8 Crossroads rather than acting as a late-game Destructive override in Episode 11.
- Get rid of the Interlude. Replace the standalone Interlude with brief flashback sequences, keeping the narrative focus locked firmly on B&R campus dynamics. In fact, have another Episode on "Being a DIK", not "Being Zoey".
- Have real rivalry. Build genuine, long-term romantic rivalries (such as with Jacob or Sage) over several episodes rather than forcing an abrupt transition during Thanksgiving; a Sage vs Zoey rivalry would've been fantastic. Quinn vs Zoey would've involved fisticuffs. Episode 12's Sage interaction with Zoey was forced and rushed; considering Sage's ability to accept others into her circle who were also romantic rivals having known history with the MC, something much more interesting would've happened..
Conclusion: A Great Character Trapped in Bad Pacing
Zoey is a fantastic character trapped inside a flawed narrative deployed into a AVN much, much too late. (She's S+, right next to Maya in our rankings.) She is healthy, almost too perfectly suited to the MC, with a huge past with him, being emotionally grounded, and deeply devoted to the MC. Yet, by isolating her in an unnecessary Interlude and delaying her main romance option path until Episode 11, and doing so in a destructive manner, DPC transformed a beloved childhood friend into a narrative Destroyer. The MC, like the rest of us, are already invested in other paths. Now, some of the "choose me" options get grayed out due to how Zoey points are scored. In fact, choosing Zoey should have been a hidden Monk run gift. If on Others, or not choosing someone on Crossroads, it certainly would've:
- saved DPC path writing, causing releases to come out faster
- kept the MC from being a heart breaking, wishy-washy jerk. Especially since he already had his Crossroads moment of whom to dedicate himself to
Like all the other late game romances or character inclusions, they're disruptive, and need to play catch up when compared to the years of content for Others and MG routes. It makes you wonder why he even bothered with this option in the first place.
Zoey would've been a great foil to Sage and Quinn, provided potential love triangles with the DIKs (everyone loves her, not just Jacob), and of course, fit in just right with the Inner Circle. She would always have the MC's back, and would naturally open up her feelings to him in a natural way (instead of a "I'm going to come to random parties and then figure out my feelings after a jealous panic attack").
Without Zoey's forced late-game pivot, Being a DIK would be a cleaner, tighter, and far more mechanically respectful experience for the player's time and choices. And released a day or two earlier.
Comments
Post a Comment